Thursday, May 28, 2015

The Magazine: the dynamic invitation of God

   This article originally appeared in "The Magazine" section of the Episcopal Cafe' web site on January 21, 2015. Because of some technical glitch I was unable to post it then. I tried today and the results can be seen below.
   The article addresses change. That last word, change, frightens many of us; some more than others. If fear is not the emotion that some feel perhaps anxiety more accurately describes it. The article explains that change (dynamism) need not be feared but can be embraced.

The original article can be found here: The Magazine: the dynamic invitation of God


The Magazine: the dynamic invitation of God

by George Clifford
In college and seminary in the 1970s, I was taught that stasis was theologically superior to dynamism. For example, course content emphasized that God—unlike humans—is immutable, unchanging, and unchangeable. I was taught that revelation ended when the canon closed. Yes, God still spoke to individuals, but God had no fresh message, revelation, or scripture to give to God’s people. My professors openly disdained groups such as the Mormons and Pentecostals who believed in God’s ongoing revelation.

For reasons I could not clearly specify at the time, I was not convinced that stasis was superior to dynamism. Illustratively, the Bible appeared to describe God changing God’s mind, though my professors were quick to point out the Biblical basis for believing that God is unchanging. Conceptualizing heaven as eternal bliss seemed more like an endless punishment: without change, what would be new? What would bring fresh excitement or joy? Intentionally using caricature, I scoffed at the notion of anyone finding drifting on a cloud, wearing a halo, and plucking a harp eternally satisfying. I pondered the dissonance between Christianity’s emphasis on stasis and Buddhism’s emphasis on the transitory nature of existence.

Post seminary, I began to perceive more clearly that the cosmos, in its entirety and in its individual particulars, is dynamic. At a quantum level, nothing is static. We humans are dynamic. Most of our cells live seven years or less. Brain physiology constantly changes as new synapses form, ions shift locations, and new patterns supplant old ones. Indeed, the existence of an enduring self is largely illusory, consisting of consciousness continually reemerging from an ever-changing physiology. The scientific description of the cosmos seemed at odds with the description implicit in much of the theology I had been taught. Furthermore, why is it unreasonable to expect that human knowledge of the divine will increase over time, even as human knowledge of the cosmos increased over time? Why is it unreasonable to speculate that a changing cosmos changes God?

I had been introduced to process thought in college (never in seminary!), and I began to read process thought again, discovering philosophy and theology that emphasized dynamism instead of stasis. This reading accelerated when I was privileged to study under Marjorie Suchocki during my DMin program. Every moment, and every entity, perishes.

Over the years, listening to people describe their journeys to me, I realized that yearning for stasis or permanency often expresses a desire or an attempt to avoid loss in one of its many forms, for example, death, a relationship ending, diminished capacity due to age or illness, or termination of a job or career aspirations. Yearning for stasis or permanency can also be a coping strategy after a loss. Alternatively, I discovered that an awareness of life’s transitory nature—although it can cause fear or anxiety—could also help a person to savor each moment and to cope with the inevitability of loss.

The Episcopal Church is living through a time of great loss. Membership is declining substantially. In many places, parish buildings are becoming liabilities instead of assets. Institutional structures at the diocesan and national levels that once provided vital and vigorous ministries are increasingly perceived as burdens and unnecessary overhead. A model of being the Church—the incarnate body of Christ—that served reasonably well for centuries now feels ever more antiquated. No longer do we live in Christendom, nor can we even pretend to do so (if one is honest, Christendom has always been more myth than fact).

Yet many of us cling to the Church that we love and that has given us life, light, and love. I sense a widespread yearning for stasis among Episcopalians fearful of change. The motives for resisting ecclesial change, when change is both inevitable and endemic to the cosmos, deserve reflection. These motives may include a misplaced allegiance to a place or building, selfish efforts to preserve power accumulated through current structures and systems, or desperate attempts to sustain an illusion of spiritual and emotional stability in a world that is changing too rapidly for comfort.

What would happen if we embraced the changes as signs of God’s continuing activity in the world? First, instead of fearing the changes, we might recognize that through the loss of buildings, structure, and influence God is cutting our attachment to idols and drawing us more firmly into God’s love. Shifting our theological paradigms would also end our futile expenditure of intellectual and emotional energy in vain attempts to preserve the illusion of stasis.

Second, we might find that dynamic patterns of being God’s people are more exciting, fulfilling, and life giving. A ritualized form of a communal meal becomes a real meal sacramentally shared. People, not physical or organizational structures, again become the Church’s basic elements. Living as a faithful remnant can also increase our awareness of God’s presence, more dramatically transforming our lives and accentuating our witness in the world.

Third, new wineskins for this new age might further multiply the effects. Crowdsourcing might replace assessments and complex budgetary processes. Direct democracy might replace our current representative form of democracy. (Incidentally, a US labor union is allowing its 15,000 members to vote directly via the internet to ratify or reject a proposed contract; Episcopalians can surely likewise vote on diocesan and national agendas).

Communications already flow unimpeded across the Church; why not allow money and power to do the same? Being a large connectional Church in prior generations required hierarchy and representational processes, but technology can now make both superfluous. A new model would take seriously Paul’s comments to the Corinthians that no part of the body is worthy of more honor than another; the body has equal need of all of its parts. Additionally, by decreasing institutional maintenance requirements, these changes would effectively expand resources available for mission.

In losing—letting go of that which we once considered gains—we can win.


George Clifford is an ethicist and Priest Associate at the Church of the Nativity, Raleigh, NC. He retired from the Navy after serving as a chaplain for twenty-four years, recently published Just Counterterrorism, and blogs at Ethical Musings.

The Search: Continuing the Walk

I'm reading Rachel Held Evans book Searching for Sunday and I posted two quotes from the book on Facebook that I thought also belonged here.


From Searching for Sunday
(entries on Facebook)

May 26, 2015
In the book Searching for Sunday by Rachel Held Evans there is a short 2 page chapter entitled Hands. She ends the chapter with this short paragraph: "Through, touch God gave us the power to injure or heal, to wage war or to wash feet. Let us not forget the gravity of that. Let us not forget the call."
I thought that was good advice on this first work day after the Memorial Day weekend.

May 28, 2015
Today in chapter 24 "Wayside Shrines" she quotes Milton, " 'What in me is dark, illumine' ".

Sunday, March 8, 2015

Grace Church Home | Grace Church, Utica

To see how the people of Grace Episcopal Church in Utica, NY follow The Way, click on the web address below.

Grace Church Home | Grace Church, Utica
http://www.gracechurchutica.diocny.org

Saturday, February 14, 2015

Bartimaeus

Mark 10:46 - 52

In today's (February 14, 2015) readings the Gospel lesson is Mark 10:46 - 52 and is labeled in The Jerusalem Bible as "The blind man of Jericho." Bartimaeus, being both blind and a beggar, calls out to Jesus as Jesus is passing by and is so loud and unruely that Jesus calls him over and asks what he wants. Bartimaeus replies that he wants to see again. Jesus says that his faith has saved him and his sight is returned. Then, as it is translated in The Jerudalem Bible, the last phrase of verse 52 says, "... and he followed him along the road." (Mark 10:52b; emphasis mine.)

This scripture can be read in two ways, as is true with much of the Bible. It can be seen as the restoring of an individual's sight, as surely it was, or it can be seen as allegory, with a hidden meaning. The allegorical meaning here, I believe, is not all that hidden. Sight can be to be visually complete or sight can mean intellectually understand. Bartimaeus asked to see again which would imply that he had been able to see previously. In the allegorical sense do we make a fuss and scream to see / understand again so that we regain or strengthen our understanding, and when we do do we then "...follow him along the road"?      

Saturday, January 24, 2015

New Wineskins



This sermon was originally posted on the web site of the Society of Saint John the Evangelist on July 7, 2013. The original sermon was by Br. Curtis Almquist and delivered on July 7, 2007.

The sermon and web site can be found here: New Wineskins

New Wineskins




Sunday, January 11, 2015

About One Person Who Followed A Calling

This cold Sunday morning (although warm compared to the recent sub-zero temperatures) I woke to discover that my car was blocked in the driveway. As I sat down to drink my first cup of coffee, wake up and contemplate what to do I picked up an old copy of an editorial page from the (Utica, NY) Observer-Dispatch that I had saved but never read. I had saved it because the title of the Op-Ed by Leonard Pitts, Jr. was, "Putting God between a rock and the wrong place." In this piece Mr. Pitts writes about Peter Kassig who had felt a calling to aid the innocent people of Syria who were caught in the violent struggles of the civil war there.

Mr. Pitts' comments can be found here:
http://www.miamiherald.com/opinion/opn-columns-blogs/leonard-pitts-jr/article4013642.html

There are numerous news stories that are the story of the moment given our 24/7 news cycle on cable TV that are here today and out of mind tomorrow as the new story of immediate importance pops up. The story about Peter Kassig could and was put into that category but as presented by Mr. Pitts there is an element of the story that is enduring and is perhaps to easily overlooked; that element is the reaction of Peter Kassig's parents. Because of their faith in the one God of many names they were able to forgive and move on; a task that many of us would find difficult if not impossible. As presented in the column, the choices of how people choose a path to follow God are held in stark contrast. Are paths chosen and then is god's name applied to them? Or does one listen to the call and then strike out on that path that God directs us to? It seems obvious that Peter Kassig listened and then began walking. It seems equally obvious that the rebels who killed him did not listen but began walking a path and then applied god's name to it. It seems equally obvious that Peter Kassig's parents choose a path of forgiveness that they heard God whisper to them.

Do we listen when God whispers to us? Do we strike out on that path that we feel directed to take or does it appear too rocky, too steep? We may not be asked to aid people in Syria or do some other dramatic task; but the questions do apply to us. I think that I have not always given the correct answer and taken the right road; but, God willing, other opportunities will occur.          



Monday, December 22, 2014

Social Being


We are created to be a social being, as God is a social Being. And as the Three Divine Persons have no life whatsoever except in this relativity of action, so have we no life whatsoever except in relative actions towards others.
-Richard Meux Benson, SSJE (1824-1915)
(From: www.ssje.org)