Sunday, April 15, 2018

War, Peace, Military Options, Pacifism; What is the Christian Response?

I have been reading Marcus Borg's book Convictions: How I Learned What Matters Most on my Fire Tablet. The morning after President (I find it difficult to use that title for this president) Trump went on television to announce air strikes on Syria the title of Chapter 10 was ironically, "Christians Are Called to Peace and Nonviolence." The chapter begins with these words, 
"I wish All Christians knew Christian teaching about peace and nonviolence as the alternative to reliance on military power and war. It is especially important for American Christians to know this. ...The United States accounts for almost half of the world's military spending.

Our armed forces are as powerful (as) those of the next dozen nations combined. No one is surprised that the U. S. Air Force is the most powerful in the world. But consider that the second most powerful is the U.S. Navy Air Force.

Moreover, we use military power not only as a deterent and as a response to violence, but also preemptively, as in the war we initiated in Iraq.

And yet, statistically we are the most Christian country in the world. About 80 percent of Americans identify themselves as Christian, and that means there are more Christians in the United States than in any other country. Is our reliance on massive military power for our security and the way we use it consistent with being Christian? Are war and the threat of violence against enemies consistent with being Christian? Sometimes? Always? Never?"

This book is about how Marcus Borg matured as a Christian. It could be considered a Christian - Faith memoir. He said that as a child, "It never occurred to me to wonder whether there was any conflict between being Christian and fighting for one's country. Christianity and patriotism went together." (Emphasis mine.) It was later in life as he begins to think more deeply about the subject that he discovers this was not necessarily true. He continues this section by writing, "Only in college did I first learn that there were several Christian attitudes toward war, including pacifism. ... I also took it for granted that our country would never wrongly become involved in a war. The United States was not only great but good. ... My conviction lasted until the early years of the Viet Nam War. In 1965, I was still justifying our involvement." Later in the chapter he writes, "My easy Christian acceptance of American use of military power vanished." he then asks, "What does it mean to give one's primary allegiance to God, as known especially in Jesus, and to be an American today? (Again emphasis mine.) 

Borg explores scripture to understand this question about clashes between violence, war, patriotism, love, and Christianity. He says, "Jesus was among those who advocated nonviolent resistance. His teaching and actions provided 'a third way' between the options of violent resistance to and submissive acceptance of domination, injustice, and violence. 

So also Paul was an advocate of nonviolent resistance." 

The various alternatives are explored in the balance of the chapter including Just War Theology, Holy War Theology, and Conventional Acceptance of War. He says that the last one, "... is seldom named but is probably the most common." As I think back to the various military conflicts that the U.S. has been involved in during my life, this last one is the most common. Given the society and the accepted norms that are part of this society I can understand why this is true. What I have more trouble understanding is how the people of this country do this with little or no thought because it is easy. More important is, "What do I make for dinner?, I can't miss my football game, what time is Sally's dance recital, etc." All important considerations during our day-to-day life, but they should not take presidence over, or completely negate how we react to questions of war and peace and what we do about it. We can't simply "go along to get along" peoples lives and suffering depend on it.

Marcus Borg also explores the various Biblical options that form a Christian's opinion about war and violence. After exploring his journey from childhood to an adult life about this subject and also  the various options available he concludes the chapter this way, 
"Following Jesus and taking seriously early Christian pacifism and subsequent teaching about justifiable war radically calls into question the widespread American Christian support of and acquiescence to our country's pre occupation with military power. ...

My own journey has not led me to the conviction that pacifism is the only legitimate Christian option. ... But I have become convinced that Christians who oppose war are more often right than wrong. Nonviolent resistance to evil, including the evils of injustice should be the primary Christian response." (Again this emphasis was mine.) 

I hear the author saying in the last quote above that the default position for Christians should be nonviolent resistance to war; not automatic acceptance of whatever our government decides to do. 

I can recommend this book to anyone who is interested in how this Christian author matured in his faith and how it might inform you about how you grow as a Christian; not only about this subject of war, peace, and violence but also about how to demonstrate a meaningful Christian witness. 

Wednesday, December 20, 2017

Mary; Out of Her Shell

On Day 27 of The Social Justice Bible Challenge the author of this reflection chooses Luke 1:39-55 as her text. This is the beautiful "song" of Mary, the Magnificat. The author describes Mary as, "... impulsive, brave, and radical" and admits that we more often think of her as, '... meek and mild..." But given the solique that Mary has in Luke's book "brave and radical" are apt descriptions.

     "Mary sings that God is not only lifting up the poor but also that God is tearing the rich and powerful down from lofty places. This is radical indeed, particularly in our time in which the wealthy are emulated." (page 104)

On this 20th day of December 2017 with a wealthy, self-centered, wannabe despot sitting in the White House who cares nothing for the "lowly" Mary's words that, "He has brought down the powerful from their thrones and lifted up the lowly; he has filled the hungry with good things, and sent the rich away empty" (v. 52b-53) in many ways seem no nearer now than it did 2000 years ago. And although we can today see organizations, both NGOs and religious institutions, who work to help to feed the hungry and cloth those in need the forces of greed and Earthly power claim victories even in this "Christian nation" where forces opposed to Mary's sentiments push for legislation that deprives those most in need and pushes wealth upward to further enrich the wealthy, currently labeled as the "1%".

What are we to make of this contrast between Mary's vision and what we think of as reality now in this time? We can look with hope at history that tells us that the despot, the extremely greedy, and those who grasp for power at the expense of others, who build their houses on the sand of these goals (gods) will see their mansions crumble and be exposed for their hollowness. But we can not wait around for history to bring this about. We must do what we can to push history along toward Mary's better vision of society. We push whenever we can by "speaking truth to power" in our conversations with others, by writing letters to Congress persons, and news outlets. By challenging the new normal when ever and where ever possible in a myriad of peaceful actions.

Reality tells us that greedy, unscrupulous people will try and sometimes succede in gaining power again and again even after others have struggled to construct a just society. So it is an on going task.  But, as Christians, it is a task that we are called to. The radical Jesus championed the poor underclass all during his time on this beautiful blue marble and he called on his disciples (that includes us) to do the same. His message at its most basic is to love God and to love our fellow human beings. He made this clear when challenged by those in authority and when he called for God's kingdom to come in a prayer that he taught his disciples.

If we ask God will give us the wisdom, and courage to help, "... thy kingdom come, thy will be done on Earth as it is in heaven."

Monday, December 18, 2017

Bartimaeus or the Rich Young Ruler

On Day 26 of the little book The Social Justice Bible Challenge the author of the piece uses as her scripture reference the incident that occurred between Jesus and Bartimaeus. The first thing that caught my attention in the scripture in verse 52b of chapter 10 of Mark was this: "...and he [Bartimaeus] followed him on the way." I like this phrase because I think that it incapsulates what discipleship is. I like it for another reason as well. Today there are those who take the name of Christian, in the church , in government, and others, and who then do not then"follow the way" of Jesus. They are more like another individual that the author of the meditation cites, the Rich Young Ruler. To quote the Rev. Canon Callaway, "... the prosperous young man who zealously kept God's law is trapped by his wealth." Trapped by his wealth seems very contemporary. That is the contrast that the author emphasises; Bartimaus gives up his sole possession, his cloak, to follow Jesus while the Rich Young Ruler can not give up his wealth. Those who preach the Prosperity Gospel, the current administration in D.C. and others who finance politicians who champion laws that favor the rich at the expense of the less fortunate are modern day versions of the Rich Young Ruler who do not follow "the way". (The encounter with Bartimaeus is found in Mark 10:46-52 and with the Rich Young Ruler in Mark 10: 10-22.)

At the end of each section of The Social Justice Bible Challenge there are questions for the reader to ponder. The first question at the end of Day 26 was, "The recent wave of refugees is one of the world's most explosive social issues. There are now 100 million refugees representing 1% of the world's population. What does Jesus' encounter with Bartimaeus and the rich man say about how we see and respond to refugees?" I'll leave you to ponder that question for yourself. However, in my estimation it speaks volumes about how the current administration in Washington treats and labels refugees; and that treatment and labeling does not reflect the direction Jesus would have us take. Those who support it do not "follow the way".

Thursday, December 14, 2017

Sheep and Goats

In The Social Justice Bible Challenge (A 40 Day Bible Challenge) edited by Marek P. Zabriskie the scripture for day 22 is Matthew 25:31-46, the parable about the sheep and the goats. In the parable Jesus likens the people who help those in need to sheep and those who do not help the less fortunate to goats. In the  parable Jesus describes those who are needy as hungry, or thirsty, or in need of clothing, or sick, or in prison. But he also discribes them as strangers.  The people that the Son of Man is addressing in the parablle ask, "And when was it that we saw you a stranger and welcomed you..." (v. 38a) or did not welcome you?

A stranger can be someone newly arrived where we live or the stranger can be someone who lives among us who we have never attempted to know. Those living among us can be "strangers" because they practice another religion, speak a different language, or have different customs. We welcome them when we accept and attempt to know about those differences. This is a way of welcoming the stranger; a direction that Jesus gives us in this parable.

Yet as a nation, self described as a Christian nation, we often reject the stranger thereby abandoning the name Christian and adopting the name USA,USA! and becoming goats herded along by the shepherds Hate, Fear, Distrust, and Insularity.

Leaving the context of the parable and reentering the context of the present day, if our eyes are wide open, we can see that there are forces in our government and our society who would have us behave as goats, not as the sheep who cared for and welcomed the stranger. These forces continually propose laws or Executive Orders that slams the door of welcome. Additionally, they propose budgets that favor the wealthy, curtail or eliminate health care for those in need and lead us toward a domination society where there is a wealthy class and an under class with a wide chasm between.

Are we as a nation to be sheep or goats? We make the decision to be goats whenever we support the forces of Hate, Fear, Distrust, and Insularity.  Or we can decide to be sheep reaching out to the stranger in our day-to-day lives or when by voting or  taking other actions we support those who would have us act like the Christian sheep we need to be.

God, help us to be sheep.

Tuesday, April 11, 2017

Jail Time

Today, April 10th 2017 the Tuesday before Easter, I read again, as I have before, that portion of Matthew 25 that says, "I was in prison and you visited me." The book of meditations Meeting Jesus on the Margins reminds us of where we meet Him. Not only in meditation and the pew; but out in the world among the less than ...

The meditation spoke of a number of clergy persons who stayed at a jail near Ferguson Missouri until a group of young people who were unjustly jailed were released. The author of this meditation said, "Jesus tells us to visit the prisioner and that's where we will find him."

It has been my experience that sometimes Jesus visits us and we usually don't expect it. In the Thrift Store at Grace Episcopal Church in Utica, NY a child walked in with her parent. She was not naked but needed clothes. She spotted a T-shirt on the rack with a heart and the word Love, held it up, and said, "Can I have this one?" Of course she could. The child Jesus was clothed.

A couple came in, another time, with a small baby. The woman said that her sister had handed her the child and said she didn't want it. So the man and woman were there to get clothing for the baby because they had nothing to dress it with. We said, "Help yourself." We clothed the baby Jesus and meet Mary and Joseph.

Two men came in newly released from jail.They had little more than the clothes on their backs and paperwork to show they had just been released. We clothed Jesus newly released.

At the end of the meditation in Meeting Jesus ...  the author says:
     "These days any number of people will tell you their opinions about how to grow the church. I have lost interest in  all of them. Because just about all of the opinions are about how I can get people to come into my church.
     Growing the church is not about getting people into my church building. Growing the church is about being out in the streets... and sitting in a jail cell.
     That's where Jesus is."

Where do you; where will you find Jesus?



Tuesday, March 28, 2017

Wishful Thinking

In the morning as I read the scriptures assigned for the day by the Revised Common Lectionary my eyes often drift to an adjacent section of scripture. That was true today and my gaze fell on Psalm 101. Four verses caught my attention, probably because of the president who currently occupies the White House and the ever-present fog of scandal, decete, and dishonesty that hangs over it. The verses that jumped out at me were 3, 4 ,6 ,and 7. This is how they are translated in the Contemporary English Version:

I refuse to be corrupt
or to take part in anything crooked,
  and I won't to be dishonest or deceitful.
...
I will find trustworthy people
   to serve as my advisors,
   and only an honest person
   will serve as an official.

No one who cheats or lies
   will have a position in my royal court.

If only ...



Monday, February 27, 2017

Oh Canada

- Oh Canada –

During the recent Presidential elections many thoughtful people would say, half in just,
that they would be going to Canada to live if Trump were elected president because
of his strident election rhetoric. Now, only a few short weeks after his surprising
election victory there is a front-page story in the Sunday edition of The (Syracuse)
Post-Standard, “U.S. border crossings to Canada on the rise.” The story details how
an increasing number of people who have immigrated to the United States because
of persecution in other countries are now choosing to leave the U.S. and cross the
border illegally into Canada. The story indicates that they are doing this because they
now fear persecution here. It is not difficult to understand why they would feel this way
given the xenophobic presidential declarations and tweets emanating from the White
House. Compare the multiple tweets that The Donnie composes with the one that Prime
Minister Truedau recently sent. According to the Post-Standard article the Prime Minister
tweeted, “To those fleeing persecution, terror, and war, Canadians will welcome you,
regardless of your faith. Diversity is our strength #WelcomeToCanada, …” This is a
sentiment one could have, in the past, expected from a head of state in the United States.
 Sadly, currently that is not true.
      Interestingly, in Sunday’s (2/26/17) meditation in “Forward Day by Day” the author,
 Minda Cox, writes about Jesus’ transfiguration on the mountain. She says in the
meditation, “… in Jesus, God is made plainly visible…” She goes on to say, “His [Jesus’]
grace and love and boundary shattering welcome (emphasis mine) are God’s welcome
 too.” Many people in this country claim to be Christians. To “be a Christian” the originally
 meaning was to be a follower of Jesus. A number of people in the United States say that
this nation is a Christian nation. To the best of my knowledge, Canada makes no such
claim. Yet which of these two nations exhibits the attitude and indeed the morality that
 Jesus teaches? Which nation “welcomes the stranger”? Scripture tell us that as Christians
 we will be known by our fruits. What “fruits” is the United States producing and what“fruits”
 are grown by Canada. The contrast is stark! The lesson should be clear.